Martin'sA Song of Ice & Fireis a bloody fight for the Iron Thronebetween several of the most powerful figures in Westeros. Whether there stillbirths and miscarriages were all his fault seems unlikely to me, but I think he was part of it. 5 kingdoms started marrying/building relations between themselves (The North, The Riverlands, The Vale, The Stromland and The Westerlands). What popular characters do you not like? But then Rheagar had to screw it up by eloping with Lyanna. It was extraordinarily unusual for a Targaryen heir to the throne to marry outside of his own family, but Rhaegar Targaryen was forced to break tradition when he didn't have an available sibling to marry. Relationships: Myrcella Baratheon/Bran Stark; Cersei Lannister/Ned Stark; Catelyn Tully Stark/Ned Stark Jon Arryn was like a second father to me and someone murdered him. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Maybe he would have taken that secret to his deathbed, as well. Fostering/warding is extremely common, however, it is usually done within one's own region.
Well, I think Edmure is about 10 years younger than Ned, so perhaps plans for him would be some kind of 2nd phase.
Although the Iron Islands have always ostensibly been a part of the Seven Kingdoms, their connection to the mainland has always been tenuous at best. But the risk would be that Jon decided that Jon Snows existence, even if secret, was too great a risk to the stability of the kingdom. Generally it's political reasons, it's also good for the kids. By Their romance ended with them dying together after yet another failed attempt at taking control of the crown. Theon was used in this manner, but it was a perfectly normal practice for high born. So in doing so, Littlefinger secured himself and Lysa a spot as one of the least healthy relationships Game of Thrones has to offer. Isn't is just like Westeros to have some decent, normal woman have to bear the brunt of some man's madness or idiocy. Honestly, I'm not sure what would have changed in the story. I honestly think there is little difference between ward and hostage, it is there to be collateral, for better or worse. So fostering him with another house is advantageous to House Stark, and also pretty common. To keep Jon safe from the Lannisters, from Robert, and from Targ loyalists. Jaime fathered four children with Cersei, all of which they claimed to be fathered by others. How well-known was Aerys Targaryen's madness outside the noble class? Craig first began contributing to Screen Rant in 2016, several years after graduating college, and has been ranting ever since, mostly to himself in a darkened room. Is it safe to say that Robert went at age 6-8, the same range of time that Sweetrobin and Ned were sent? News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. King Aerys was controversially killed by Jaime Lannister, and Robert himself claimed the throne, since he was the man to rebel first and he had bested Rhaegar in battle. (Spoilers Extended). Jon was initially told to execute her but after she escaped the two spent some very cold yet cozy nights out in the frozen wilderness. But we should know better than to trust anything that seems too good to be true in Game of Thrones. As such he was sent to the most available High Lord. Iwas under the impression that the marriage deal was made before Denys died. I think the story would play out the way it normally does. House Arryn and the Eyrie < Prev Chapter. He peered in as he saw his father, Eddard Stark, and the queen, Cersei Lannister, both fully naked as the day they were born. While it was true that Jon unearthed the truth about Jamie and Cersei's incestuous relationship, Game of Thrones season 4 confirmed that Lysa was in fact the one who killed Jon Arryn. I agree, plenty of reasons to foster. You're absolutely right. Something Balon certainly was aware of, instantly putting the wheels in motion once Theon was returned. Hand Drawn Map of Westeros with sigils ( SPOILERS MAIN). We loved watching their love story continue to unfold and when they parted ways for the last time, it was a real tearjerker. Jon Jones Opens Up on Return vs. Ciryl Gane, Francis Ngannou's UFC Release. That's not entirely true. So if Ned told Jon Arryn the truth of Jon Snow's parentage what would have been different in the overall story? It can be either handed over as a sign of trust or to forge an alliance, but the underlying principle of we can't mess with these guys or we lose an heir is always there.
That's what I keep hearingby those accounts shouldn't have Edmure have been there as well?
Robert Arryn was to be fostered (ie. Ned was barely given any choice, as it was more of a king's command. The southron ambitions also explains why Hoster never seemed to consider marriage with the Freys, even to strengthen their tense relationship. Hoster Tully forking over his eldest daughter to Walder Frey may not have seemed like an appealing prospect for the High Lord or Cat, but clearly House Frey was more powerful than anyone in Westeros wanted to admit, and it would have been smart for the seat of the Riverlands to shore up their strength through an allegiance with the Freys. IF ever it could be said that a non-regal child was born more politically powerful than the child of a king, it would have been said about all of the Stark children, for they were born between two noble houses, as opposed to being born of just one (as most Targaryens are). It has some grounds, and is probably one of the reasons Ned was fostered South. But before that when the kids are 8, Steffon on the small council and cousin to Aerys, Roberts grandmother is a Targaryen. Craig has previously been published on sites such as Den of Geek, and after many coffee-drenched hours hunched over a laptop, part-time evening work eventually turned into a full-time career covering everything from the zombie apocalypse to the Starship Enterprise via the TARDIS. Is any of the members of the small council announced to chair the small council and to serve as the King's proxy during his absence (powers that would otherwise rest with the Hand of the King)? RELATED:Game Of Thrones: The D&D Moral Alignments of House Greyjoy. Well deserved if we say so ourselves. WebJon noun. Whether she left willingly or not doesn't matter; it's not something that's done either way. Every Game of Thrones fan remembers where they were for Ned Stark's untimely demise, can hum the tune of . Robert'sbrothers and alliesclash with his incestuous, scheming former allies, House Lannister, while those with a less legitimate claim to power operate in the shadows. As to the man himself, we can't really say anymore. So yes, the most toxic award goes to Stannis Baratheon and Melisandre. Until Littlefinger that is. If the realm was so well-governed when Tywin Lannister was Hand of the King, why was the Kingswood, which was so close to the capital, infested with bandits? Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Of course, there was an untold, yet vital, chapter in these events. Jon didn't turn anti-Targ until Aerys murdered his heir, Elbert, and then demanded Ned and Robert as well. My guess would be that the mastermind were the maesters, getting panicky on how dragon obsessed the Targs became, and probably decided after they nearly hatched them at Summerhall to end their line. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Jon feels more modern than the traditional John, but some may find it an overly slight variation But unlike Ned he would not berate a man like Tywin just for honor alone, risking everything instead of being pratical. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Stannis disliked everyone and was disliked by everyone. Or, was it some kind of Grand Scheme to bring both the Stark and the Baratheon houses together to form some kind of coalition? Please pass us the tissues. His parents died in 278 AC. As they grew, the two boys became close companions and regarded the childless Jon as a second father. How dry does a rock/metal vocal have to be during recording? Jump to Chapter Chapter 1: Chapter 18: 16. I would appreciate it, if someone has a sense as to why both Ned and Robert were fostered by Jon Arryn, to please reply with their. And of course, Robert wound up marrying Cersei to bring the Westerlands into the fold. Why is sending so few tanks to Ukraine considered significant? It's in Ned XV when he has that dream of the tourney at Harrenhal. Tensions were already high as Aerys committed violent acts against his own people and became increasingly paranoid, but the real motivation behind Robert's Rebellion was, typically, romantic in nature. So this will be speculation and logical inference. It doesnt get lower than convincing a partner to burn their already scarred daughter alive as everyone watches. We can only assume it is her own feeble attempt at closeness with another human as her descent into madness seems to have driven everyone else off. Musim dingin akan datang. Elements of Robert's Rebellion are alluded to or shown via flashback inGame of Thrones, but the intricacies of the war are largely glossed over. There's a link for it in my signature). R+L=J Chapter 20: 18. who is deceitful and honorless behind Robert rebellion and a anti-Targaryen who was as power hungry as Tywin ? Both of his daughters had quite interesting storylines, and have the potential to be intriguing characters in the Jon Snow spinoff, but they may have endured less suffering had they remained in the North.Their fate may have still been dark at Winterfell, but It's Barbry Dustin talking shit. Maquinas vending ultimo modelo, con todas las caracteristicas de vanguardia para locaciones de alta demanda y gran sentido de estetica. He was Lord of the Eyrie and the head of House Arryn, one of the Great Houses of Westeros. I think Eddard in a way saw Theon as a ward as opposed to a hostage, but for the Greyjoys and Theon himself he was to be seen as nothing but a hostage, a spoil of war. It's possible he could have wanted years later to tell key people what had happened but not right after Jon was born and as he was traveling from the Tower of Joy. While there were many relationships in Game of Thrones, these are a few that really stand out in our minds from the cute to the cringe, from the toxic to the tumultuous, from the aww to the awful, and everything in between. Jon just started a war to save his adopted sons from the Targaryen dynasty and he just found out his adopted sons betrothed had a child with the former prince, and the other adopted son swore to protect this nephew. Telling Robert would just result in an innocent child getting killed, Ned possibly being executed for treason, and plunge the realm into more war so hed keep the secret to himself. I think Robert was at the Vale as a young man. Families used to send their kids willingly to learn about other parts of the world and how things are done and to forge alliences. At this point, Robert Baratheon was Lord of the Stormlands, andhad been lined up to marry a woman from another noble house, Lyanna Stark. By The marriage was entirely to bring Hoster Tully into the war on the rebels' side. Are the models of infinitesimal analysis (philosophically) circular? Why did Eddard Stark bring Ice to King's Landing? Jon Arryn seems to have done nothing untoward with Robert or Eddard, and viewed them as his own adopted sons, especially after their fathers died and he lost his own heirs one by one. "We have your bloodline, step out of line and we can end it." The best thin Jon could have done would have benn to never tell anyone, which is identical to not telling him. Tywin? Gilly had not had the easiest of lives before meeting Sam. It could go a few different ways from there. As for Baratheon--he was entrusted with a sensitive mission to Essos--to find a bride for the crown prince. Jon's marriage wasbeforethe Battle of the Bells, look it up. It's generally accepted that the death of Jon Arryn is the spark that signals the beginning of the Game of Thrones. That essay put into words something that my mind had been pondering over for quite some time. When Ned Stark uncovered and revealed his knowledge about Cersei and Jaime Lannister's incestuous relationship in Game of Thrones, it proved to be his fatal Aided by other rebel houses, Robert Baratheon and Ned Stark led a war lasting approximately a year. Cant send him to The Vale, now) and stays in KL. And Cat's marriage to a sleazeball who loves her is a small price to pay to avoid war. Hoster? Perhaps the Hand's office was simply left vacant, as it was later on in. Jaime was capable of being monstrous, but it's very possible that a marriage to someone like Cat could have tempered his worst impulses. Robert was an orphan, Ned was not, but he came from the great Northern I think that it's more about forming alliances. When Tyrion went on trial for the murder of his nephew Joffrey, Shae appeared as a witness, claiming Tyrion had been violent towards her and even kidnapped her. And he didn't marry his way into the alliance until after the war had started, and even that came about only after the next heir after Elbert, Denys Arryn, was killed at the Battle of the Bells and then Denys' infant son died as well.
jon arryn and ned stark relationship
Martin'sA Song of Ice & Fireis a bloody fight for the Iron Thronebetween several of the most powerful figures in Westeros. Whether there stillbirths and miscarriages were all his fault seems unlikely to me, but I think he was part of it. 5 kingdoms started marrying/building relations between themselves (The North, The Riverlands, The Vale, The Stromland and The Westerlands). What popular characters do you not like? But then Rheagar had to screw it up by eloping with Lyanna. It was extraordinarily unusual for a Targaryen heir to the throne to marry outside of his own family, but Rhaegar Targaryen was forced to break tradition when he didn't have an available sibling to marry. Relationships: Myrcella Baratheon/Bran Stark; Cersei Lannister/Ned Stark; Catelyn Tully Stark/Ned Stark Jon Arryn was like a second father to me and someone murdered him. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Maybe he would have taken that secret to his deathbed, as well. Fostering/warding is extremely common, however, it is usually done within one's own region. Well, I think Edmure is about 10 years younger than Ned, so perhaps plans for him would be some kind of 2nd phase. Although the Iron Islands have always ostensibly been a part of the Seven Kingdoms, their connection to the mainland has always been tenuous at best. But the risk would be that Jon decided that Jon Snows existence, even if secret, was too great a risk to the stability of the kingdom. Generally it's political reasons, it's also good for the kids. By Their romance ended with them dying together after yet another failed attempt at taking control of the crown. Theon was used in this manner, but it was a perfectly normal practice for high born. So in doing so, Littlefinger secured himself and Lysa a spot as one of the least healthy relationships Game of Thrones has to offer. Isn't is just like Westeros to have some decent, normal woman have to bear the brunt of some man's madness or idiocy. Honestly, I'm not sure what would have changed in the story. I honestly think there is little difference between ward and hostage, it is there to be collateral, for better or worse. So fostering him with another house is advantageous to House Stark, and also pretty common. To keep Jon safe from the Lannisters, from Robert, and from Targ loyalists. Jaime fathered four children with Cersei, all of which they claimed to be fathered by others. How well-known was Aerys Targaryen's madness outside the noble class? Craig first began contributing to Screen Rant in 2016, several years after graduating college, and has been ranting ever since, mostly to himself in a darkened room. Is it safe to say that Robert went at age 6-8, the same range of time that Sweetrobin and Ned were sent? News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. King Aerys was controversially killed by Jaime Lannister, and Robert himself claimed the throne, since he was the man to rebel first and he had bested Rhaegar in battle. (Spoilers Extended). Jon was initially told to execute her but after she escaped the two spent some very cold yet cozy nights out in the frozen wilderness. But we should know better than to trust anything that seems too good to be true in Game of Thrones. As such he was sent to the most available High Lord. Iwas under the impression that the marriage deal was made before Denys died. I think the story would play out the way it normally does. House Arryn and the Eyrie < Prev Chapter. He peered in as he saw his father, Eddard Stark, and the queen, Cersei Lannister, both fully naked as the day they were born. While it was true that Jon unearthed the truth about Jamie and Cersei's incestuous relationship, Game of Thrones season 4 confirmed that Lysa was in fact the one who killed Jon Arryn. I agree, plenty of reasons to foster. You're absolutely right. Something Balon certainly was aware of, instantly putting the wheels in motion once Theon was returned. Hand Drawn Map of Westeros with sigils ( SPOILERS MAIN). We loved watching their love story continue to unfold and when they parted ways for the last time, it was a real tearjerker. Jon Jones Opens Up on Return vs. Ciryl Gane, Francis Ngannou's UFC Release. That's not entirely true. So if Ned told Jon Arryn the truth of Jon Snow's parentage what would have been different in the overall story? It can be either handed over as a sign of trust or to forge an alliance, but the underlying principle of we can't mess with these guys or we lose an heir is always there. That's what I keep hearingby those accounts shouldn't have Edmure have been there as well? Robert Arryn was to be fostered (ie. Ned was barely given any choice, as it was more of a king's command. The southron ambitions also explains why Hoster never seemed to consider marriage with the Freys, even to strengthen their tense relationship. Hoster Tully forking over his eldest daughter to Walder Frey may not have seemed like an appealing prospect for the High Lord or Cat, but clearly House Frey was more powerful than anyone in Westeros wanted to admit, and it would have been smart for the seat of the Riverlands to shore up their strength through an allegiance with the Freys. IF ever it could be said that a non-regal child was born more politically powerful than the child of a king, it would have been said about all of the Stark children, for they were born between two noble houses, as opposed to being born of just one (as most Targaryens are). It has some grounds, and is probably one of the reasons Ned was fostered South. But before that when the kids are 8, Steffon on the small council and cousin to Aerys, Roberts grandmother is a Targaryen. Craig has previously been published on sites such as Den of Geek, and after many coffee-drenched hours hunched over a laptop, part-time evening work eventually turned into a full-time career covering everything from the zombie apocalypse to the Starship Enterprise via the TARDIS. Is any of the members of the small council announced to chair the small council and to serve as the King's proxy during his absence (powers that would otherwise rest with the Hand of the King)? RELATED:Game Of Thrones: The D&D Moral Alignments of House Greyjoy. Well deserved if we say so ourselves. WebJon noun. Whether she left willingly or not doesn't matter; it's not something that's done either way. Every Game of Thrones fan remembers where they were for Ned Stark's untimely demise, can hum the tune of . Robert'sbrothers and alliesclash with his incestuous, scheming former allies, House Lannister, while those with a less legitimate claim to power operate in the shadows. As to the man himself, we can't really say anymore. So yes, the most toxic award goes to Stannis Baratheon and Melisandre. Until Littlefinger that is. If the realm was so well-governed when Tywin Lannister was Hand of the King, why was the Kingswood, which was so close to the capital, infested with bandits? Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Of course, there was an untold, yet vital, chapter in these events. Jon didn't turn anti-Targ until Aerys murdered his heir, Elbert, and then demanded Ned and Robert as well. My guess would be that the mastermind were the maesters, getting panicky on how dragon obsessed the Targs became, and probably decided after they nearly hatched them at Summerhall to end their line. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Jon feels more modern than the traditional John, but some may find it an overly slight variation But unlike Ned he would not berate a man like Tywin just for honor alone, risking everything instead of being pratical. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Stannis disliked everyone and was disliked by everyone. Or, was it some kind of Grand Scheme to bring both the Stark and the Baratheon houses together to form some kind of coalition? Please pass us the tissues. His parents died in 278 AC. As they grew, the two boys became close companions and regarded the childless Jon as a second father. How dry does a rock/metal vocal have to be during recording? Jump to Chapter Chapter 1: Chapter 18: 16. I would appreciate it, if someone has a sense as to why both Ned and Robert were fostered by Jon Arryn, to please reply with their. And of course, Robert wound up marrying Cersei to bring the Westerlands into the fold. Why is sending so few tanks to Ukraine considered significant? It's in Ned XV when he has that dream of the tourney at Harrenhal. Tensions were already high as Aerys committed violent acts against his own people and became increasingly paranoid, but the real motivation behind Robert's Rebellion was, typically, romantic in nature. So this will be speculation and logical inference. It doesnt get lower than convincing a partner to burn their already scarred daughter alive as everyone watches. We can only assume it is her own feeble attempt at closeness with another human as her descent into madness seems to have driven everyone else off. Musim dingin akan datang. Elements of Robert's Rebellion are alluded to or shown via flashback inGame of Thrones, but the intricacies of the war are largely glossed over. There's a link for it in my signature). R+L=J Chapter 20: 18. who is deceitful and honorless behind Robert rebellion and a anti-Targaryen who was as power hungry as Tywin ? Both of his daughters had quite interesting storylines, and have the potential to be intriguing characters in the Jon Snow spinoff, but they may have endured less suffering had they remained in the North.Their fate may have still been dark at Winterfell, but It's Barbry Dustin talking shit. Maquinas vending ultimo modelo, con todas las caracteristicas de vanguardia para locaciones de alta demanda y gran sentido de estetica. He was Lord of the Eyrie and the head of House Arryn, one of the Great Houses of Westeros. I think Eddard in a way saw Theon as a ward as opposed to a hostage, but for the Greyjoys and Theon himself he was to be seen as nothing but a hostage, a spoil of war. It's possible he could have wanted years later to tell key people what had happened but not right after Jon was born and as he was traveling from the Tower of Joy. While there were many relationships in Game of Thrones, these are a few that really stand out in our minds from the cute to the cringe, from the toxic to the tumultuous, from the aww to the awful, and everything in between. Jon just started a war to save his adopted sons from the Targaryen dynasty and he just found out his adopted sons betrothed had a child with the former prince, and the other adopted son swore to protect this nephew. Telling Robert would just result in an innocent child getting killed, Ned possibly being executed for treason, and plunge the realm into more war so hed keep the secret to himself. I think Robert was at the Vale as a young man. Families used to send their kids willingly to learn about other parts of the world and how things are done and to forge alliences. At this point, Robert Baratheon was Lord of the Stormlands, andhad been lined up to marry a woman from another noble house, Lyanna Stark. By The marriage was entirely to bring Hoster Tully into the war on the rebels' side. Are the models of infinitesimal analysis (philosophically) circular? Why did Eddard Stark bring Ice to King's Landing? Jon Arryn seems to have done nothing untoward with Robert or Eddard, and viewed them as his own adopted sons, especially after their fathers died and he lost his own heirs one by one. "We have your bloodline, step out of line and we can end it." The best thin Jon could have done would have benn to never tell anyone, which is identical to not telling him. Tywin? Gilly had not had the easiest of lives before meeting Sam. It could go a few different ways from there. As for Baratheon--he was entrusted with a sensitive mission to Essos--to find a bride for the crown prince. Jon's marriage wasbeforethe Battle of the Bells, look it up. It's generally accepted that the death of Jon Arryn is the spark that signals the beginning of the Game of Thrones. That essay put into words something that my mind had been pondering over for quite some time. When Ned Stark uncovered and revealed his knowledge about Cersei and Jaime Lannister's incestuous relationship in Game of Thrones, it proved to be his fatal Aided by other rebel houses, Robert Baratheon and Ned Stark led a war lasting approximately a year. Cant send him to The Vale, now) and stays in KL. And Cat's marriage to a sleazeball who loves her is a small price to pay to avoid war. Hoster? Perhaps the Hand's office was simply left vacant, as it was later on in. Jaime was capable of being monstrous, but it's very possible that a marriage to someone like Cat could have tempered his worst impulses. Robert was an orphan, Ned was not, but he came from the great Northern I think that it's more about forming alliances. When Tyrion went on trial for the murder of his nephew Joffrey, Shae appeared as a witness, claiming Tyrion had been violent towards her and even kidnapped her. And he didn't marry his way into the alliance until after the war had started, and even that came about only after the next heir after Elbert, Denys Arryn, was killed at the Battle of the Bells and then Denys' infant son died as well.
Share Buyback Accounting Entries Ifrs, Mt Sac Cares Act Emergency Grant, Does Brad Paisley Have Ms, Mary Claire Krasinski, Articles J